| Year | Winner | Points | Runner Up | Points |
| 2002 | Luft, Kevin | 4315 | McDevitt, Dave | 4191 |
| 2003 | Arndorfer, Mike | 5491 | Luft, Kevin | 5263 |
| 2004 | McKewon, Clint | 5144 | Dunne, Mike | 4744 |
| 2005 | Lewon, Jeff | 4698 | Dunne, Mike | 4348 |
| 2006 | Kennedy, Dick | 4322 | McDevitt, Pete | 4274 |
| 2007 | Schroeder, Dave | 4061 | Kennedy, Dick | 4060 |
| 2008 | McDevitt, Dave | 5216 | Schroeder, Ben | 4939 |
| 2009 | Schroeder, Ben | 5488 | Colling, Travis | 5259 |
| 2010 | Grasso, Tony | 4352 | Strong, Cameron | 4321 |
| 2011 | Theis, Jerry | 6353 | DiMeo, Joe | 6262 |
| 2012 | Johnson, Darrin | 5993 | Colling, Travis | 5430 |
| 2013 | McDevitt, Dave | 4608 | Wetz, Grant | 4605 |
| 2014 | Schroeder, Dave | 5133 | Kennedy, Dick | 5125 |
| 2015 | Gallant, Andrew | 5640 | DiMeo, Joe | 5606 |
| 2016 | ??? | ??? | ||
| Champion | Runner-up | |||
| 2 | Schroeder, Dave | 2 | Dunne, Mike | |
| 2 | McDevitt, Dave | 2 | Kennedy, Dick | |
| 1 | Luft, Kevin | 2 | Colling, Travis | |
| 1 | Arndorfer, Mike | 2 | DiMeo, Joe | |
| 1 | McKewon, Clint | 1 | McDevitt, Dave | |
| 1 | Lewon, Jeff | 1 | Luft, Kevin | |
| 1 | Kennedy, Dick | 1 | McDevitt, Pete | |
| 1 | Schroeder, Ben | 1 | Schroeder, Ben | |
| 1 | Grasso, Tony | 1 | Strong, Cameron | |
| 1 | Theis, Jerry | 1 | Wetz, Grant | |
| 1 | Johnson, Darrin | |||
| 1 | Gallant, Andrew |